Challenging historical narratives

Title separator

Speaking
class

speaking lesson on Thanksgiving

LESSON OVERVIEW

The main objectives of this speaking lesson are to:

  • discuss the history of Thanksgiving and modern-day celebrations;
  • watch a video about Native Americans’ feelings about the holiday;
  • talk about challenging historical narratives.

In this speaking lesson on Thanksgiving, students discuss what they know about the holiday and its customs and traditions. They look at its true history and watch a video in which Native Americans do a word association task related to the holiday. Students discuss adjacent ideas surrounding challenging historical narratives, like defacing monuments and state-issued apologies. They also have an optional vocabulary task.

C1 / Advanced
C2 / Proficiency
45 min
60 min
Speaking ClassUnlimited Plan

This is a Speaking Class worksheet. It includes a variety of tasks that let your students practise their speaking skills. This lesson format does not focus on grammar or vocabulary. Learn more about it here.

WARM-UP AND DISCUSSION

This speaking lesson on Thanksgiving starts with a warm-up. Students think of a national holiday and discuss points in the boxes (e.g. origins, attitudes, celebrations). Then, students move on to talking about Thanksgiving and provide two short facts about it. After that, they look at the words in the boxes and guess the modern-day Thanksgiving traditions they refer to (e.g. potluck, football). At this point in the speaking lesson on Thanksgiving, you can do an optional vocabulary activity. Students read sentences and think of a word that fits in each gap, using the first and last letters to help them. There is a synonym provided in brackets at the end of the sentence. After this activity, they read two opposing narratives of Thanksgiving and discuss the questions (e.g. How do you think these narratives influence the way people celebrate Thanksgiving?).

VIDEO AND MORE DISCUSSION

At this point in the speaking lesson on Thanksgiving, students prepare to watch the video. Students read the beginnings of some comments about Thanksgiving made by Native Americans in the video. They guess how they might end (e.g. I don’t know what the first Thanksgiving was, but I highly doubt…). Then, they watch the video and use some provided adjectives to say how they feel about it (conflicted, appalled). Next, they discuss questions, which move from Thanksgiving to broader questions of challenging historical narratives (e.g. Do you know of any celebrated histories in your country that involve myths or inaccuracies?). The speaking lesson on Thanksgiving ends with an opinion task. Students read opinions about historical narratives (e.g. Changing the names of national holidays (e.g. Unthanksgiving Day) is better than creating alternative holidays). They choose some statements and explain if they agree or disagree.

WORKSHEETS

Comments

Title separator

Leave a Reply

  1. Andrew Gill

    attacking American traditions, how edgy

  2. Regina Batara

    This new interface is confusing. I miss the old one!

    1. Stan

      Hi there, Regina! What are you referring to when you say ‘interface’? You mean the new homepage for logged-in users? Or something related to this page/lesson in particular?

  3. RichKatTheKing

    I love Thanksgiving! 😀

  4. teachergerson

    I liked the vocabulary exercises, but they should be available to students in the PDF version. Usually the exercises are only available in the slides, which makes it hard to assign them as homework or as an activity prior to the lesson.

    1. Leslie Corpuz

      A work around could be to make copy of those slides and save as a pdf.

    2. Justa

      We’re happy you like the extra vocab activities 🙂 Actually, they are also available in the teacher’s PDF version. You can find them on the last page, so you can print them and hand them out to your students. We don’t add them to the student’s PDF version because they’re optional and each teacher can decide on their own whether to use them or not with a given student or group.

  5. English Lab Teacher

    The vocabulary in this one was really good! However, the topic and information was partly historically inaccurate, very biased, extremely left-wing hate America, and total offensive. Since the material is created by Polish authors, I’d suggest that topics like this focus on Polish history to avoid such castigation.

    1. Megan

      Hi there! That’s great that you found the vocabulary useful. As with all our lessons, the sources we implement are used predominantly to spark discussion and promote language learning; we conduct a lot of research, and we do not claim absolute veracity or historical accuracy However, we are sorry you found the lesson offensive, biased, and inaccurate. On that note, it might be useful for you to know that most of our current authors are not Polish. I, myself, am Irish. Hope that helps!

  6. Caroline Aparecida Vaz de Araujo Medeiros

    I absolutely love this lesson plan! Very useful vocabulary and it was great to problematize about colonialism. I also loved the video it´s so good to give voice to those people who were so marginalized. Very accurate. Congratulations.

    1. Megan

      Thanks so much for this comment. I’m happy to hear you extracted such a viewpoint from the lesson! I really appreciate that feedback.

  7. yellowhub

    I really appreciated the creative ideas this lesson inspired for my Thanksgiving classes. Finding it slightly one-sided, I complemented it with a charming video presenting the dominant narrative (I removed the original texts) and adjusted the questions to foster balanced and thought-provoking discussions. I let the students do the thinking.
    It proved to be a fantastic resource, and by tailoring/removing some exercises to suit different levels, I was able to use it effectively across all my groups. Thank you!
    By the way, neither my students nor I knew much about Thanksgiving, so it was a valuable learning experience for all of us. 😉

    1. Megan

      Hi! Thanks for this comment. It’s always great when teachers tailor our resources to suit their needs and it sounds like you made a really good lesson! We’re so glad you found the worksheet useful and that you and your students had such a valuable discussion.

Browse other materials recommended for you

Title separator
advanced expressions for complaining
C2 / Proficiency
Standard Lesson 60 min
Loading

Quit your bellyaching!

General

With this lesson, students talk all about complaining! They discuss the benefits, practicalities, and downsides of the behaviour, and learn lots of advanced vocabulary. They also watch a video about ‘chronic complainers’ and discuss the concept in more detail.

esl lesson on contracts
C2 / Proficiency
Standard Lesson 60 min
Loading

The undersigned hereby agrees to…

Business General

Students talk about contracts! They learn vocabulary, share opinions and experiences, and watch a video in which a lawyer turns everyday language into legalese. They also draft sections of a ‘classroom contract’.

C1 / Advanced
Critical Reading Club 30 min / 45 min
Loading

Gen Z’s penchant for sad music

General Lifestyle

Students read and discuss an article about Gen Z’s preference for sad music and learn vocabulary for describing sad music and listener behaviour. They also talk about changes in music trends, analyse comments, and share opinions on the topic.

talk about uncertain situations
C1 / Advanced | C2 / Proficiency
Speaking Class 45 min / 60 min
Loading

Uncertain times in business

Business General

In this lesson, students talk about attitudes towards difficult situations. They revise useful vocabulary and watch a video about VUCA, a framework to interpret challenging circumstances. Students also talk about how some difficult situations were handled in real life.

vocabulary on challenges and achievements
C1 / Advanced
Standard Lesson 60 min
Loading

In a league of your own

General

In this lesson, students discuss awards and famous individuals, and learn vocabulary on challenges and achievements. They explore Olympic Games quotes, watch a video about an athlete, and engage in discussions on success.

advanced prepositions
C1 / Advanced
Standard Lesson 60 min
Loading

Advanced prepositions

General

Work on prepositions with this lesson! C1 students practise advanced prepositions in various contexts, discuss personal experiences and explore prepositional phrases. They also study verbs with dependent prepositions and prepositions in binomials.

advanced vocabulary for discussing philosophy
C2 / Proficiency
Standard Lesson 60 min
Loading

Beauty in the broken (life philosophies)

General

Explore philosophy with this lesson! Students discuss the idea of imperfection, watch a video about Kintsugi and practise advanced vocabulary. They also talk about their experiences and other philosophies around the world.

B2 / Upper Intermediate | C1 / Advanced
Critical Reading Club 30 min / 45 min
Loading

Mockumentaries and other comedy series

General

With this lesson, students discuss mockumentaries like The Office! They also explore other comedy series and learn some descriptive vocabulary. They discuss opinions on famous comedy series and look at proposals for other potential programmes.

C1 / Advanced | C2 / Proficiency
Critical Reading Club 30 min
Loading

Therapy speak

General

Engage students in reading an article about therapy speak! In this lesson, they talk about therapy, discuss the pros and cons of therapy speak and discuss changing perspectives on mental health.

Show more lessons

Questions

Title separator

Is there a minimum subscription period if I choose a monthly subscription?

No, there's no minimum required number of subscription months. You can cancel any time you want. Basically, you can sign up and then cancel your subscription the next day, which will mean you have access for 1 month and won't be charged again.

What currencies can I pay in for my subscription?

Our default currency is USD (American dollar), but you can also pay in EUR (euro), GBP (British pound sterling) or PLN (Polish zloty). You can change the currency you want to pay in at the Pricing page before selecting a subscription plan.

How can I edit an e-lesson plan?

You can get your own editable copy of an e-lesson plan and make changes to it. To do so, either (1) make a copy of it on your Google Drive (preferable method) or (2) download it in a Powerpoint format (but formatting might be a bit off so we can’t guarantee that it will work well).
Read more FAQ
Title separator

ESL Brains

Forgot password?
or continue with